When
your students lose interest in class, what do you usually do to inspire them? I
usually use poems to generate discussions and most students including adults
find it very challenging. The interactions in class and in students’ online community
about the interpretation of a poem can effectively rekindle the passion to
think critically and to use rhetoric to express opinions. Occasionally, some students
complained that poetry was too difficult and they asked for films. At present, using films to enhance students’ analytical skills is not a new idea (Culkin,
1970; Maynard, 1969, 1971, 1977, as cited in Champoux, 2007). Many others have
reported successfully using films in teaching a broad range of disciplines or
topics, such as political science, American Studies, French, group dynamics, science,
and anthropology (Champoux, 2007). However, for some people, especially in
traditional classroom education, using films is viewed inappropriate. Teachers
showing films in class without clearly identifying the purpose of the lesson to
the audience are sometimes criticized as if they were just trying to kill time.
Therefore, before using films, teachers need to gain insight, advantages and
disadvantageous of films as a teaching resource.
The article “Film as a Teaching
Resource” by Joseph E. Champoux (2007) discusses film as a resource for
teaching organizational behavior and management theories and concepts. The
author points out that the unique qualities of film make it a communication
medium that effectively enhances the learning process. The functions of film in
teaching followed by the advantages and disadvantages of using film as a
teaching tool are discussed at the end of the article.
Functions of Films in Teaching and its
advantages
Using films in traditional or
virtual classrooms can personalized both the teaching styles for instructors and
the lesson for learners. In this article, the author interestingly describes
different functions of film in teaching that can be applied with different teaching
styles, teaching goals, and contents. Films can serve as case studies,
experiential exercises, metaphors, satires and symbolisms to make the lessons
more understandable. Films can lead to rich discussions and reinforcement of
concepts and theory. Students can analyze selected scenes in small groups using
some background knowledge of problem solving and the theories and concepts they
are studying to recommend a decision approach. In other words, discussion on
films can activate models. Moreover, unusual shots, sequencing, lighting,
and the use of colors in film can convey symbolism that helps students practice
abstract thinking. Film is an excellent
medium for giving meaning to theories and concepts better than printed or
spoken words (Champoux, 2007).
Disadvantages of Film in
Teaching
While using film in class is convenient,
motivating, and attention stimulating, there are some critical drawbacks. First,
the film content might distract some students from the target theories and
concepts. Students are easily moved by its sentimental contents and scenes that
they forget why they are watching it. Second, showing a whole film in class
takes time away from other classroom activities. For this problem, the author suggests
using selected scenes of twenty minutes or less to make students focus on
specific theories or concepts. The film and scene selection is also important. Teachers
need to carefully determine whether the scene selected makes its point
efficiently and worth the use of class time. Third, admittedly, a lot of scenes
distort reality. By watching films, students can misunderstand some basic concepts
of other cultures resulting in inappropriate interaction with people from that
culture.
Summary
This article described how and
why to use film as a teaching resource. With various functions, films can be
used as cases, as a source of information for experiential exercises, or
present unusual experiences to students. Using films as a teaching tool also
has strengths and weaknesses. Therefore, teachers need to thoughtfully design a
lesson with films for students’ maximum benefits.
Champoux,
J. E. (2007). Film as a
Teaching Resource. Journal of Management Inquiry, September
2007. Retrieved April 15, 2012 from http://symptommedia.com/wp-content/uploads/teaching-resource.pdf.